LG after out-iPhoned the Iphone. Now it is exiting the cellphone small business wholly

In January 2007, a customer electronics large announced the world’s 1st entire touchscreen cellphone. Critics showered it with praise for its daring and smooth design. It introduced a number of months afterwards and turned a big strike. But this wasn’t Apple. LG Electronics pioneered this breakthrough, collaborating with luxurious brand name Prada on a cellphone with a capacitive touchscreen — the variety observed on all modern day smartphones — that hit the marketplace just in advance of the authentic Iphone. 

The Prada Phone garnered accolades before the Apple iphone was even a detail, with an early style mockup successful an iF Item Design and style Award in 2006 in Germany. But that didn’t matter. When Steve Careers took the stage — also in January 2007 — at Apple’s then-annual Macworld convention with the Iphone in hand, he adjusted the earth. 

The LG Prada Cellphone defeat out the Apple iphone as the 1st capacitive touchscreen handset.


The $777 Prada Mobile phone, which sold additional than a million models and birthed two sequels, has been relegated to the dustbin of obscure cellphone trivia.

“I was a tiny bit upset with Steve Work,” mentioned Ramchan Woo, an LG govt who ushered in flagship phones like the LG G4 and G5, in a 2016 interview the place he shared his ideas about Jobs’ authentic presentation. Employment experienced wowed the earth with the Apple iphone, and no just one was supplying LG its thanks. 

There is myriad causes why the Iphone persists and the Prada didn’t. But that intersection in time and the wildly divergent routes taken by the two firms illustrate the struggles and uneven trip that marked LG’s foray into the cell phone business. The South Korean tech conglomerate, which accounts for virtually 4% of that nation’s economic climate, on Sunday night time explained it will shut down its mobile small business in July, even as it was on the verge of releasing one of its most enjoyable telephones ever in the LG Rollable. 

The ignominious conclusion to LG’s phone enterprise is fitting thinking about its two a long time as a handset maker that continuously tried — and unsuccessful — to get to that upper strata of cellphone gamers. The corporation never fully capitalized on the domestic title recognition developed on a household of products and solutions that includes televisions, laptops, washing machines and kitchen area appliances. Moreover, it was beset by an inferiority complicated to crosstown rival Samsung.

Alternatively, LG’s history with telephones ping-pongs between dealing with existential threats and eking out average hits just profitable plenty of to keep it in the game as a 2nd-tier player. It shares a equivalent story to Motorola and Nokia, feature phone stalwarts that had been swallowed up by the disruptions brought on by the smartphone. Even though LG never liked their heights of achievements, it did control to survive more time. 

That is no more time the scenario, with the telephone enterprise about to be shuttered. The subsequent is the twist-filled tale of perennial second fiddle LG. 

Dominance in characteristic phones

Smartphones these days employ a one, simple layout — a glass display encased in a rectangular slab manufactured of plastic, glass or aluminum. Wanting for a little wide variety? Go commit $2,000 on a foldable Galaxy Z Fold 2. 

The cellular phone marketplace in the early to mid-2000s was wilder, with flip phones, sliders, candy bar phones and even lipstick-formed phones. Heck, there were sweet bars that turned into flip telephones. From a layout point of view, it was wonderful — even if all you could do was deliver a textual content information and make a mobile phone simply call. Specifically robust telephones could participate in Mp3s. 

LG thrived in this environment right after entering in 2002. And though the firm was never a planet-beater like Nokia or Motorola, steadily holding a one-digit slice of the world wide market place for its 1st six a long time, it picked up steam in essential markets like the US. It was here that it boasted a solid double-digit share of the company many thanks to interactions with carriers like Verizon Wireless and Sprint. 

LG liked good results with standout telephones like the slide-out Shine and a myriad of flip telephones featuring generic alphanumeric code names. Then in 2004, Motorola launched the blockbuster Razr, speedily environment the standard on ultra-slender clamshells and threatening to get rid of any momentum designed up by LG. 

The pursuing calendar year, LG had a response. It experienced put in a calendar year operating on a new music cell phone (it was virtually dubbed “audio cellular phone” in the course of its development) when Chang Ma, then-head of mobile product and internet marketing, fixated on a catchier identify for the candy bar-shaped handset. 

The LG Chocolate revived the firm’s telephone efforts in the “dumb phone” times.


The LG Chocolate was born. 

“It seemed excellent, it truly is distinctive and I just experienced to seize it and have it,” Ma reported of his first impact of the prototype in an job interview performed in 2015 when he ran the US organization, noting the playful name was an less complicated provide than listing out technical specs like speaker fidelity and file potential. 

LG executives credit history the Chocolate for assisting hold the Razr momentum at bay and sustaining its advancement throughout those early decades, and at the very least a single CNET editor nevertheless appears on this traditional dumb phone with nostalgic bliss. 

As the decade went on, LG located even more success with so-referred to as “speedy-messaging devices,” which featured total keyboards for a lot easier texting, a kind of precursor to smartphones. Hong-Joo Kim, a further LG govt who earlier worked on the mobile group, named that stretch “the glory yrs” for its feature phones. 

Unbeknownst to LG, those people glory several years have been about to conclude. 

Behind from the get started

It was 2009, and smartphones have been continue to a deluxe novelty in spite of the physical appearance of the Iphone and Google’s initial Android phone, the G1 from HTC. LG even now moved tens of millions of aspect phones at just about every of the US carriers and didn’t deem Apple a threat due to the fact it was tied to AT&T as an special. Android was even more of a area of interest issue. LG’s attribute phone business, in the meantime, had peaked at a tenth of the world’s sector for telephones, in accordance to Statista

“Ironically, 2009 was the finest 12 months for earnings and revenue for mobile,” Kim said.

Publicly, the company expressed self confidence, but privately, executives knew they have been behind. That yr, its major hitter was the enV Contact, a massive (for its time) candy bar cellphone with a 3-inch touchscreen that unfolded to expose a complete QWERTY keyboard, twin speakers and a lesser interior display. Verizon pumped it up as a possible rival to the Iphone with its standard video games and rudimentary world wide web browser. 

It was not. And LG realized it. 

“Some of us thought we were being far too satisfied with the achievements of the feature cellular phone,” Kim reported. “We were being so late getting ready for smartphones.”

The variance would be starkly felt just a couple of months later when Verizon shifted gears to its next flagship, the Motorola Droid, which debuted in October 2009. The Droid launched with the backing of a substantial $100 million promoting campaign and a partnership between Motorola, Verizon and Google, and was credited with pushing Android phones into the mainstream. 

Other gamers like Samsung and HTC have been piling on with Android phones of their possess, but LG hesitated. 

“There was no ‘fire below my butt’ mentality,” reported a previous executive at LG’s US device who did not want to be named. 

It wasn’t until eventually August of the adhering to 12 months that LG set its foot to the pedal, promising a blitz of 10 Android smartphones and a tablet below the “Optimus” brand to near out 2010. 

By that time, the Iphone had shed its exclusivity deal with AT&T and expanded to Verizon. Samsung, meanwhile, experienced embarked on its own mission to consider command of the smartphone industry with the start of its Galaxy S franchise and a substantial promoting blitz comparable to the Verizon Droid marketing campaign. 

LG, perennially in Samsung’s shadow, lacked the exact promoting firepower irrespective of a flood of solutions. Lots of of LG’s earliest Android attempts had been price range-pleasant possibilities that didn’t stand out from the rising pack of entrants. 

“We failed to seize the thoughts share of users,” Kim claimed. 

Beginning of a G

LG Electronics is structured significantly like Samsung: It is aspect of a greater household of firms under a single proprietor, recognised in Korea as a chaebol. The LG conglomerate’s various enterprises focus in exhibit, digital camera tech and chemical substances. 

These distinct models contributed the skills and components that served breathe daily life into LG’s smartphone aspirations. By 2012, LG was again in the recreation with the higher-stop Optimus G, which benefited from enhanced show, battery and digicam. It was a hit both of those critically and commercially, selling far more than 1 million models within just its initially four months. CNET editor Lynn La at the time identified as it “definitely the ideal telephone LG has at any time offered.”

The LG Nexus still retains a warm position in the hearts of old-school Android supporters. 

Josh Miller/CNET

The Optimus G was just the initial of a potent a person-two punch that calendar year. LG’s enhancement operate on that gadget led to the introduction of Google’s Nexus 4 cell phone, which also drew essential praise for its capacity to pack in large-top quality components at what CNET editor Andrew Hoyle referred to as a “cut price-basement value.” Even now, Android supporters glance back again fondly at the Nexus 4. 

LG experienced averted yet another crisis. 

The subsequent several years would cement its flagship position with the effective comply with-up to the Optimus G, the G2, as nicely as the much more experimental LG G Flex, a person of the initially phones to aspect a curved display screen and a back with a self-therapeutic polymer and the product of a 5-yr improvement cycle. 

“They’ve occur again quite sturdy,” Jeff Bradley, then-senior vice president of units at AT&T, stated in a 2014 job interview about LG. “We ended up emotionally energized about it when we first noticed the G Flex.”

(AT&T reported on Monday that it designs to continue on supporting LG units on its networks as the enterprise can make its changeover.)

But even with revenue that exceeded expectations, LG struggled to industry the units and even communicate a distinct identification. For occasion, executives couldn’t concur on what the “G” essentially stood for. Terrific? Excellent, as in its tagline, “Life’s Very good”?

The LG G Flex 2 was an early precursor to the foldable phones we see nowadays. 

Josh Miller/CNET

LG, unwilling to commit a large amount on internet marketing, also tied by itself to exclusives with carriers. That contrasted with Samsung’s strategy of generating its Galaxy S phones accessible almost in all places, putting the emphasis on its manufacturer above partners like Verizon or AT&T. LG, as well dependent on carrier help, could not establish its have connection with consumers. 

“It was easier to attraction to the carriers so we could secure the far better lock-in status,” Ma explained. “I do not have any regrets on the approach at the time, for the reason that that was the only matter that we could do. But there was a small bit of a backfire.”

Ironically, it was only when LG started off to consider much more threats with its G franchise that it seriously started out to come to feel the burn. 

A daring step backfires

Tech fans often bemoan the lack of key improvements in the telephone market. We complain that each and every new iteration of a flagship mobile phone lacks big recreation-shifting attributes, and that the 12 months-in excess of-year advancements are incremental. 

Then an individual basically usually takes a threat. 

Immediately after LG’s G4 confronted criticism for a deficiency of new functions further than custom backing with resources like leather-based, the business took the daring step of introducing a modular customization method the following calendar year with the G5. This came at a time when the modular principle was catching on through Google experimenting with initiatives like Undertaking Ara. 

It was 2016, and LG held its launch occasion at the Sant Jordi Club sporting arena in Barcelona throughout the Cell World Congress trade clearly show. The organization had scheduled its celebration to run in the afternoon, a handful of several hours ahead of Samsung’s personal Unpacked function that night. 

Armed with one thing diverse, LG hoped to snatch the highlight away from its rival. “We do not see excitement any more,” Juno Cho, then-president of LG’s cellular organization, stated throughout the start occasion, placing up the G5 as the antidote to “mobile phone exhaustion” that experienced established in with less breakthroughs on new equipment.

And to be reasonable, the Galaxy S7 failed to blow any person absent with spectacular variations. But perennially a grasp of presentation, Samsung’s Unpacked function highlighted a secret visitor in Mark Zuckerberg, who memorably walked via a group loaded with attendees sporting VR headsets before earning his surprise appearance on stage. (In hindsight, you can find something unsettling about Zuckerberg going for walks among us as we sat there unaware.)

Samsung experienced received this showdown.  

Samsung’s Galaxy S7 Edge held additional sway than the LG G5, inspite of the one of a kind modular feature. 

Sarah Tew/CNET

It also failed to aid that the G5 modular system was a clunky set up that needed you to electricity your cellular phone down prior to swapping out elements like a digital camera grip or excess battery. LG promised a universe of extras, dubbed “Good friends,” that could be integrated into the G5, but couple of materialized. Woo excitedly said in an job interview that he hoped LG would get credit for switching how you use a mobile phone. 

Critics, nonetheless, right away jumped on it. 

“The LG G5 seems wonderful on its own, and it can be going to have to promote that way — customers don’t purchase modular goods,” shopper tech analyst Avi Greengart, now with Techsponential, tweeted at the time. 

They also didn’t acquire the G5, which marked a enormous blow to LG’s fortunes and any attempt to experiment. 

The past (rollable) gasp

Smarting from the formidable bet on a buzzy concept that backfired, LG reverted to a “standard” flagship telephone with the G6, entire with metallic body, enhanced cameras and prime-of-the line processor. 

It was wholly forgettable. 

The G series would operate for another two several years, which would see the synthetic intelligence-themed “ThinQ” identify tacked on to the stop to tiny influence. It  would ultimately see its finish with the G8 in 2019. LG changed it with the Velvet in 2020, when the V60 ThinQ 5G ongoing its V sequence operate as its superior-conclude system that also served as an inexpensive option to Samsung. 

For a extend, it felt like LG was heading via the motions, still not able to compete with the varsity players. 

The LG Wing is a strange phone, but it speaks to the business seeking one thing unique yet again. 

Angela Lang/CNET

But anything happened in the slide: LG got the urge to experiment all over again. It released the Wing, a telephone with two shows, one stacked on the other, with the upper display screen ready to swivel to horizontal mode, forming a T condition. It was strange and bizarre, harking again to the more adventurous feature telephone days. CNET’s La explained that “the structure wasn’t as mad or pointless as it would seem.” 

In a dim, pandemic-ridden year, it was just the kind of distraction we needed in our life. 

Then at the virtual CES in January, LG produced even far more buzz by teasing a short video clip of its Rollable cellular phone, which CNET verified was real, with ideas to go to market this 12 months. 

But now it is useless, without even a prospect of ending up a trivia concern like its predecessor, the LG Prada Mobile phone. 

This story at first ran on April 5 at 5 a.m. PT.